Why is my ice cream melting and everything else is frozen?

Picture this: You come home after a long day, craving a bowl of your favorite ice cream.

You open the freezer, and to your horror, you find that your ice cream has melted into a puddle, while everything else in the freezer is perfectly frozen.

We’ve all been there, and it can be extremely frustrating. But have you ever wondered why this happens?

In this post, I’m going to break down the science behind why ice cream melts at a higher temperature than other frozen foods and discuss the common reasons why your ice cream might not be freezing properly in the freezer.

Let’s dive in!

Why is my ice cream melting and everything else is frozen?

Ice cream is a complex mixture of fat, sugar, air, and other ingredients that freeze at different temperatures. As a result, ice cream melts at a higher temperature than other frozen foods.

Here’s why:

Fat content: Ice cream has a higher fat content than most other frozen foods. The fat in ice cream prevents it from freezing as hard as other frozen foods, which means it melts at a higher temperature.

Sugar content: Sugar lowers the freezing point of water. Since ice cream contains a lot of sugar, it freezes at a lower temperature than other frozen foods. This also means that it melts at a lower temperature than other frozen foods.

Air content: Ice cream contains air, which gives it a lighter, creamier texture. However, the air in ice cream also lowers its freezing point, which means it melts at a higher temperature than other frozen foods.

Temperature fluctuations and freezer storage conditions can also affect ice cream’s texture. If the temperature in your freezer fluctuates too much, the ice cream can become icy or grainy.

Learn: How to fix grainy ice cream for a better taste experience?

Similarly, if you store your ice cream in a warm spot in the freezer, it can start to melt and refreeze, which can cause it to become icy and crystallized.

Why is my ice cream not freezing in my freezer?

If your ice cream is not freezing properly in the freezer, there are a few common reasons why this might be happening:

Dirty freezer: If your freezer is dirty or has a lot of frost buildup, it can affect its ability to cool properly. This can cause your ice cream to melt and not freeze properly.

Low freezer temperature: If your freezer is not set to the right temperature, it can affect how well your ice cream freezes. Make sure your freezer is set to at least 0°F (-18°C) to ensure that your ice cream freezes properly.

Overloading the freezer: If you have too many items in your freezer, it can affect the airflow and prevent your ice cream from freezing properly. Make sure you leave enough space around your ice cream container to allow for proper airflow.

To ensure that your ice cream freezes properly, make sure you store it in the back of the freezer, where it’s the coldest.

You can also cover your ice cream with plastic wrap or aluminum foil to prevent ice crystals from forming on the surface.

Why is my ice cream soft in the freezer?

Some types of ice cream are naturally softer than others in the freezer. This is because of the following factors:

Stabilizers: Ice cream contains stabilizers, such as guar gum and carrageenan, which help it maintain its texture and prevent it from becoming icy or grainy. However, some types of stabilizers can also make ice cream softer in the freezer.

Emulsifiers: Ice cream contains emulsifiers, such as lecithin, which help to blend the fat and water in the ice cream. Emulsifiers can also make ice cream softer in the freezer.

Overrun: Overrun is the amount of air that’s whipped into the ice cream during the churning process. Ice cream with a higher overrun will be softer in the freezer than ice cream with a lower overrun.

This is because the air helps to give the ice cream a lighter texture, but it also makes it more susceptible to melting.

So, if you’re looking for ice cream that will hold its shape in the freezer, look for types with lower overrun, such as gelato or custard-based ice creams.

In addition to the above factors, the temperature of your freezer can also affect the texture of your ice cream.

If your freezer is too warm, your ice cream will be softer, and if it’s too cold, it can become icy and grainy.

To avoid this, make sure your freezer is set to the optimal temperature of around -18°C (0°F). You can also try storing your ice cream in the coldest part of your freezer, which is typically the back or bottom.

Another tip is to avoid constantly opening and closing your freezer door, as this can cause temperature fluctuations that can affect the texture of your ice cream.

But ice…

Many people believe that all frozen foods should have the same texture in the freezer, but that’s simply not true.

Different types of frozen foods have different textures and structures, which can affect how they freeze and how they should be stored.

Ice cream, in particular, is a unique frozen food that requires special attention to maintain its texture and quality.

When compared to other frozen foods, such as ice cubes or frozen vegetables, ice cream has several distinct differences.

For example:

  • Ice cream contains more fat than most other frozen foods, which can make it softer and more prone to melting in the freezer.
  • Ice cream contains stabilizers and emulsifiers, which can affect its texture and how it freezes.
  • Ice cream is often stored in a container that is not airtight, which can allow air and moisture to enter and affect its texture.

The freezing point of different foods can be affected by a variety of factors, including the type and amount of water they contain, the presence of salt or other solutes, and the amount of air that is whipped into them during the freezing process.

In general, foods with a higher water content freeze at a lower temperature than foods with a lower water content.

Additionally, adding salt or other solutes to a food can lower its freezing point, while whipping air into a food can raise its freezing point.

The impact of freezer burn

Freezer burn occurs when ice crystals form on the surface of frozen food, causing it to become dehydrated and lose its quality.

Ice cream is particularly susceptible to freezer burn, as it has a high water content and can easily develop ice crystals.

To prevent freezer burn, it’s important to store ice cream in an airtight container and avoid repeatedly opening and closing the freezer door.

The role of ice crystals

Ice crystals are a natural part of the freezing process and are what give ice cream its texture.

However, if ice crystals become too large or too numerous, they can cause ice cream to become grainy or icy.

To prevent this, it’s important to store ice cream at the proper temperature (ideally around -18°C) and to avoid repeatedly thawing and refreezing it.

The best ways to thaw frozen ice cream

Thawing ice cream too quickly can cause it to become soupy and lose its texture.

The best way to thaw ice cream is to transfer it from the freezer to the refrigerator and allow it to thaw slowly over several hours.

If you need to thaw ice cream quickly, you can place it in a bowl of warm water, but be sure to stir it frequently and check it often to ensure it doesn’t become too soft.

Should I store ice cream in the door of the freezer or on a shelf?

It’s best to store ice cream on a shelf in the freezer rather than in the door, as the temperature in the door can fluctuate more than on a shelf.

Additionally, storing ice cream in the door can cause it to be exposed to more air and moisture, which can affect its texture.

Can I refreeze melted ice cream?

While it is safe to refreeze melted ice cream from a food safety perspective, it is not recommended as the texture and quality of the ice cream may be compromised.

Refreezing ice cream can lead to the formation of large ice crystals, which can cause the ice cream to become icy and grainy.

Instead of refreezing melted ice cream, it’s best to consume it within a reasonable time or use it in recipes that call for softened ice cream.

How long can I store ice cream in the freezer before it goes bad?

The length of time ice cream can be stored in the freezer before it goes bad depends on a variety of factors, including the temperature of the freezer and the quality of the ice cream.

Generally, ice cream can be stored for up to 2-3 months in a standard freezer without experiencing any major changes in texture or flavor.

However, if the freezer is not cold enough or if the ice cream is exposed to air, it may develop freezer burn or become icy and grainy.


In summary, ice cream melting in the freezer can be a common problem for many people, but it is not necessarily a sign that the freezer is not working properly.

Understanding the factors that affect the freezing point of ice cream, such as the type of stabilizers and emulsifiers used, can help prevent ice cream from melting and becoming too soft in the freezer.

It is also important to properly store ice cream in the freezer, keeping it in the coldest part of the freezer and minimizing exposure to air and temperature fluctuations.

Finally, readers are encouraged to share their own tips and tricks for keeping ice cream frozen, as well as to continue learning more about the science of frozen desserts.

Leave a Comment